When it comes to succulent, slow-cooked meats, it’s hard to top pork shoulder. Whether you patiently roast it to yield meaty goodness encased in crispy skin or you throw the meat into the slow cooker for mouthwatering pulled pork, it’s hard to go wrong with the cut. But, say you’re keen to experience the tender meat magic, yet pork shoulder isn’t available. Perhaps surprisingly, one of the best substitutes is actually beef chuck.
The composition of fat and meat is similar between pork shoulder and beef chuck. After all, the two cuts come from the same general region of their respective animal, sourced from an area just above the front legs. Give them time and low heat, and they both break down into richly flavored shreds of meat. Plus, reaching for beef chuck caters to those steering away from pork for cultural, dietary, and other reasons. Throw in the fact that beef chuck is inexpensive, and the appeal of the pork shoulder substitute becomes clear.
Beef chuck cooks down similarly to pork shoulder
While there are undoubtedly parallels between pork shoulder and beef chuck, note the nuance to make sure your dish shines. For one, pork roast delights with its crispy skin, which is entirely absent on beef. Furthermore, the cut is classically sold with an attached layer of fat that runs directly underneath the skin; if you’re hoping to serve a whole pork roast that’s sliced per each guest, the experience doesn’t quite translate.
Instead, look to swap the two in shredded applications; think stews, soups, and a chopped roast that appears in dishes such as tacos and sandwiches. Even opposed to fatty pork butt, pork shoulder offers plenty of fat. Analogously, chuck roast also boasts a high fat content. Take the time to cook down both meats, and you’ll be rewarded with a rich flavor and succulent texture. The shredded, meaty consistency satiates in similar ways, making them both a delicious protein option.